S SAIMEIYA Cosmetic Manufacturing
S SAIMEIYA Cosmetic Manufacturing
The Challenge Test: Reading a PET Report
Home/ Encyclopedia/ Quality

The Challenge Test: Reading a PET Report

A challenge test report is short and easy to misread. What the organisms, log reductions and neutralisation step actually tell you, and when the test has to be repeated.

Quality 4 min read 16 Nov 2026

Key takeaways

  • A challenge test simulates contamination; it does not predict how a consumer will use the jar.
  • Five or six organisms are used, with Pseudomonas and the mould usually deciding the outcome.
  • Without a validated neutraliser, survivors are undercounted and a failure can look like a pass.
  • A multi-challenge suits wide-mouth jars with a long PAO; a single challenge often does not.
  • Retest after any change to the preservative system, the water phase or the primary pack.

A preservative efficacy test answers one question: does the preservation system control microbial growth in this formula, in this pack, under the conditions of use. The report is short and the table is easy to misread, so knowing what each column means prevents both false comfort and unnecessary reformulation.

1. What the Test Answers

It is a laboratory simulation of contamination, not a guarantee of market safety. Five or six organisms are introduced at a known level, and the population is counted over 28 days. The result tells you whether the system recovers, and how quickly. It says nothing about how a consumer will actually treat the jar.

2. The Organisms

Typically three bacteria, one yeast and one mould: Staphylococcus aureus, Escherichia coli, Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Candida albicans and Aspergillus brasiliensis. Pseudomonas is the one that finds water systems and survives weak preservation. The mould is usually the hardest to reduce and the slowest to recover from.

3. What a Pass Looks Like

Criteria vary by standard, but the shape is consistent: a rapid fall in bacterial counts within the first days, no re-growth through day 28, and a smaller required reduction for moulds because they are harder to kill. Read the actual acceptance criteria in the report, not the summary word pass.

4. Inoculum, Neutralisation and Error

A test is only valid if the neutraliser actually stops the preservative when the sample is plated. Without a validated neutralisation step, surviving organisms are undercounted and a failing system looks adequate. Ask whether neutralisation was validated; if the answer is vague, the whole table is unreliable.

5. Single Challenge or Multiple

A single challenge answers whether the system works once. A multi-challenge, with re-inoculation after the first recovery, answers whether it still works in a jar that is opened for months. For a wide-mouth jar with a twelve-month PAO, the single challenge is often the wrong test.

6. Why a Lab Pass Fails in the Market

Three reasons recur: the sample was tested in a different pack, the consumer introduces more contamination than the protocol assumes, or the formula changed after the test. A fragrance swap or a pH adjustment can move the result. Retest after any change that touches the preservation system or the water phase.

7. pH, Water Activity and the Rest

Preservatives have pH windows: organic acids work at the acid end, quaternaries are less sensitive. Water activity matters more than most briefs acknowledge, so a high-glycerin formula can pass with less preservative. Both parameters belong in the report, and both explain why a copied formula fails in a new base.

8. Reading the Table in Ten Minutes

Look at the log reduction at each sampling point, not only the final column. A system that reaches the target at day 28 alone is borderline, even when it passes. Check the recovery pattern for the mould. Then check whether the test pack matches the production pack. Those three checks catch most weak reports.

9. When to Repeat

Repeat after a preservative change, a significant water-phase change, a pack change that alters exposure, or a stability failure. Do not repeat for a colour or fragrance change unless the fragrance has antimicrobial character. Each run costs weeks, so timing it with the stability programme saves a month.

10. Where it fits

Preservation is a documentation topic as much as a chemical one. Read the system design background in the encyclopedia, check quality notes in news, and see the product families in products. For water-based formats such as facial masks, keep the report with the batch file.

Reference: Microbiology laboratory methods notes, 2025

Start a project

Ready to put your name on a formula?

Send a brief and our formulation team will come back with a costed proposal, sample plan and timeline — typically within two working days.

WhatsApp +86 13149918467
WeChat QR code Scan to add WeChat
Call +86 13149918467 [email protected]
Quote WhatsApp Call Products