Key takeaways
- Smaller droplets need more emulsifier, so size and emulsifier load must be decided together.
- A narrow droplet distribution matters more than a small mean for texture and stability.
- Homogenise while the oil phase is liquid, typically at 70-75 C, not after cooling.
- Excess shear incorporates air, which whitens the cream and shortens shelf life.
- Match energy per unit mass, not time, when scaling from bench to production.
An emulsion is only as stable as the size of its droplets and the film around them. Homogenisation sets that size, and the settings that produce a good bench sample are rarely the settings that reproduce it at a tonne. Understanding the mechanism makes the scale-up argument shorter.
1. What Homogenisation Does
It reduces droplet size by applying shear, cavitation and turbulence to the oil phase while it is dispersed in water. Smaller droplets mean more interfacial area, which requires more emulsifier, but also slower creaming because Brownian motion competes with gravity. The balance decides the texture and the shelf life.
2. Rotor-Stator and High Pressure
A rotor-stator head works in the tank and suits viscous creams; a high-pressure valve gives a tighter size distribution for low-viscosity emulsions. Most cosmetic plants run rotor-stator for creams and a piston homogeniser or a mill for serums. The two are not interchangeable at the same energy input.
3. Target Sizes in Practice
Typical cosmetic emulsions sit between 1 and 10 micrometres, and a narrow distribution is more valuable than a small mean. A cream with a 3 micrometre mean and a long tail of 20 micrometre droplets will show grit and cream faster than one with a flat 5 micrometre curve, because the large droplets rise or coalesce first and drag the texture with them.
4. Energy, Temperature and Time
Size falls with energy input only up to the point where the emulsifier film can cover the new surface. Beyond that, droplets recoalesce and the size plateaus or rises. Homogenising at 70-75 C keeps the fat phase liquid; cooling before homogenisation usually produces a coarser result.
5. Over-Processing Has a Cost
Excessive shear can denature proteins, strip a polymer’s structure and incorporate air. Air is the quiet problem: it whitens a cream, reduces density and shortens shelf life through oxidation. A vacuum-rated vessel is worth more than a larger homogeniser in most plants.
6. The Emulsifier Has to Keep Up
An emulsifier blend has a coverage capacity. If homogenisation halves droplet size, interfacial area doubles and the same emulsifier load is now stretched thin. Either the emulsifier percentage rises or the target size relaxes. Formulators who ignore this see a stable bench sample split in a 200 kg batch.
7. Measuring What You Made
Optical microscopy gives a fast, subjective view and catches grit. Laser diffraction gives a distribution and is the number worth recording in a specification. Measure at the same point in the cooling ramp every time, because droplet size read at 70 C and at 30 C are different measurements.
8. Why Bench Formulas Split on the Line
Bench homogenisers run for two minutes at 12,000 rpm; production heads run for twenty minutes at lower tip speed, or the reverse. The two processes deliver very different energy densities. Matching energy per unit mass, not time, is the only scale-up rule that reliably transfers a result.
9. Scale-Up Rules That Work
Fix the tip speed, fix the number of passes, and record the batch temperature at each pass. Then verify droplet size on the first production batch and adjust one parameter. Changing speed, time and temperature together makes the next batch unrepeatable, which is the real cost of a rushed scale-up.
10. Where it fits
Homogenisation connects formulation to equipment. Read the emulsifier background in the encyclopedia, check process notes in news, and see the ranges in products. For emulsion lines such as face creams, record droplet size in the batch record from the first run.
Reference: Formulation development notes, 2025