Key takeaways
- Trace metals come from the ore body and the process, so control is per lot, not per supplier.
- Lead, arsenic, mercury and cadmium are the standard four; brand lists often add nickel.
- ICP-MS after microwave digestion reaches ppb levels, but an incomplete digest under-reports.
- A pass or fail COA without numbers and method is not evidence of compliance.
- Lake colours are approved by product category, so the certificate must name the intended use.
Colour cosmetics are built on mineral raw materials, and minerals arrive with whatever the deposit contained. Lead, arsenic, mercury and cadmium are the four that appear in every specification, and the numbers that matter are parts per million in the pigment, not in the finished product alone.
1. Why Pigments Carry Metals
Iron oxides, mica, talc, kaolin and the lakes used for certified colours are mined or precipitated. Trace metals come from the ore body, from processing equipment and sometimes from the water used in manufacture. No supplier can guarantee zero; the question is whether the level is characterised and controlled lot by lot.
2. The Metals That Matter
Lead, arsenic, mercury and cadmium are the standard four, with antimony, nickel and chromium appearing in some brand standards. Nickel and chromium matter for sensitisation as much as toxicity. The list should come from the destination market and the brand’s restricted substance list, not from a generic template.
3. Typical Specification Levels
Many brand specifications sit around 10 ppm for lead, 3 ppm for arsenic, 1 ppm for mercury and 3 ppm for cadmium in the raw material, though the exact figures belong to the market and the customer, so the brief should name them. A supplier COA that reports only pass or fail, with no number and no method, is not evidence of anything.
4. How the Test Works
Inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry after microwave digestion is the standard method. Detection limits are in the parts per billion range, so the analytical capability is rarely the constraint. Sample preparation is: mica and talc dissolve slowly, and an incomplete digest under-reports the result.
5. Sample Preparation Errors
Three failures are common: an incomplete acid digest leaving mineral residue, a calibration curve built without matrix matching, and no spike recovery to prove the method worked. Ask for the recovery figure. A laboratory that reports 95-105% recovery on a spiked sample is telling you the number means something.
6. Lot-to-Lot Variation
A single annual test on a pigment says nothing about the drum that arrives in June. Mine sources shift over a season, and a supplier may run several at once without changing the trade name. Sampling per lot, with a retained sample from each, is the only way to connect a finished-goods result to an incoming material. For a colour cosmetic, retain a sample of every pigment lot used.
7. Colour Additives and Lakes
Certified colours and their lakes are regulated as colour additives in several markets, with permitted uses by product category. The lake substrate, usually alumina, brings its own metal profile. A lake approved for a rinse-off product is not automatically approved for a lip product, and the batch certificate should name the intended use.
8. Particulates and Labelling
Some markets require specific labelling for powders that may be inhaled, and for nanomaterials including certain titanium dioxide and zinc oxide grades. Particle size distribution then becomes a compliance document, not only a performance parameter. Keep the supplier’s specification with the technical file.
9. Documents to Hold
Per lot: certificate of analysis with numbers and method, safety data sheet, specification with the metal limits, and the allergen or restricted-substance declaration. Per supplier: a quality agreement and an audit record. A buyer’s technical team usually asks for the lot COA and the specification; having both ready shortens every pre-shipment review.
10. Where it fits
Trace metals are a sourcing and documentation issue. Read the pigment background in the encyclopedia, check compliance notes in news, and see the product families in products. For colour lines such as facial masks, keep a lot COA per pigment.
Reference: Regulatory compliance notes, 2025